EFFICIENCY
BEGINS WITH AN 'E'
David Price looks at one of the weirdest 'speakers to come from Wharfedale,
the late '70s high-efficiency E70.
There were never many great 1970s loudspeakers. Possibly because the
wisdom of the time was that big, muscular transistor power amps were the
way ahead, 'speakers became increasingly complex and power hungry. Multi-driver
designs using polypropylene and Bextrene meant slow transients, phase problems
and hopelessly complicated crossovers that degraded the sound.
British companies were perhaps the worst offenders, turning out 'speakers
with such heavy, reactive loads and low sensitivity that only a brace of
Naim NAP250s could get a squeak from them. Everything from Linn's Isobarik
to the BBC LS3/5a ate power amps for dinner - hardly a synergetic approach.
So when Wharfedale launched their E series in 1977, many audiophiles
thought they'd flipped their lid. The flagship E70 (81cm high, the 'E'
standing for 'efficiency' and 70 being its internal cabinet volume in litres)
had an outrageously high 94dB sensitivity and a benign typical impedance
of 10ohms, meaning even a portable radio could drive it! This was all too
much for the sniffy BBC brigade, which pointed to its lumpy frequency response
(60Hz-16kHz +/-4.5dB), bass reflex design and paper-coned drivers (shock,
horror) as a sign of poor breeding.
To make matters worse, the Es had Wharfedale's corporate garish driver
trim rings and 'cor-blimey' Ford Capri fish-net grilles, laying them open
to accusations of being cheap and flashy. In short, they were a bit of
a joke amongst the great and good of loudspeakers, making it hard to take
their admirable design philosophy seriously.
A pity, because underneath its brash exterior lurked an interesting
'speaker which was nothing like its British contemporaries. Indeed, if
anything, it owed more to JBL and Klipsch, two other brands that little-Englander
audiophiles sniggered at.
In action, the E70 was disarmingly fast and loud with real confidence
and boldness. On Classical and Jazz it wasn't much cop, but give it Rock,
Soul or (best of all) Disco and it was boogie wonderland! It caught the
energy and speed of the music in a way that BBC-style 'speakers could never
do. Drums had great attack and weight, basslines were fast and bouncy while
vocals projected strongly out into the room and cymbals hit you between
the eyes. Chic's 'Le Freak' was never the same again!
The downside was the bass, of which there wasn't a lot. All that cabinet
volume and the big 25cm woofer were for efficiency rather than accuracy,
so things were distinctly light and lumpy downstairs. Nor were the twin
10cm midrange units the sweetest around, meaning that along with the horn-loaded
soft dome tweeter, things could get a little tiring. But worst of all was
the E70's stereo imaging, which thanks to its higgledy-piggledy driver
arrangement and wide front baffle was as far from a point-source as you
could get.
Still, all this pales into insignificance when you consider the E70's
special talent, which is working with valve amps. Give it a good tube power
source and the result is almost magic - its amp-friendly load and the inherent
smoothness of valves makes for a marriage made in hi-fi heaven.
Nowadays mint pairs of E70s go for £150 (but pay half that for
old nails), while their smaller but equally worthy E50 brothers cost £100.
In 1979 the monster E90 appeared, the reinforced PRO version of which ended
up as a PA 'speaker in many schools and cinemas.
The subsequent E30 and E20 were also reasonable enough but lacked the
E70's star quality - pay £200, £70 and £50 respectively
for mint examples. But whatever you do, don't overlook Wharfedale's Efficiency
series - to paraphrase Jarvis Cocker, your system will whizz when sorted
for Es!
This review was published in the May 98 issue of Hi-Fi
World. No material may be reproduced from this review without the written
permission of the publisher. Copyright Audio Publishing Limited
|