SWEET
16
Naim's CDS was one of the company's seminal early adventures in digital
audio. David Price listens to this sixteen-bit special.
Funny isn't it? This time ten years ago, CD player manufacturers were
scrambling to get their first 'Bitstream' digital disc spinners out into
the shops. Philips had pipped everyone to the post with its famous CD850/II,
and the rest, as they say, is history. All of a sudden, multi-bit CD players
and DACs were about as fashionable as your little sister's old Bros singles.
All was not what it seemed though. While Marantz fast began to clean
up in the budget market with its Bitstream CD52SE, the upper echelons of
audio proved less eager to jump onto the good ship 'One Bit'. There were
two reasons for this - the first was simply why spoil a winning formula?
If you'd spent two years honing your multibit based masterpiece, why
go back to the drawing board and do it all again simply in order to write
that magic word 'Bitstream' on your player's front panel? The second reason
was that some tortured souls actually believed multibit sounded better
- or should we say 'more musical' - anyway.
Naim's CDS was born from this idea. It was not a trendy piece of cutting
edge high tech but it sure as hell sounded good. Launched in 1991, the
CDS wasn't a conventional two box player like its rival Linn Karik/Numerik,
but was split into CDS CD player and XPS power supply sections. This was
because the company considered (and still does) that the separation of
transport and DAC caused more problems than it solves.
The biggest was jitter, which Naim characterised as causing increases
in non-correlated distortion, lower resolution and inferior signal-to-noise
ratios. True to form, the CDS also lacked a digital output - heresy to
a world full of ever-so-trendy high-end two-box players!
The CDS duly comprised a proprietary full width Naim box housing an
XPS power supply, on top of which another box sat containing the CD player
itself. Inside this were selected versions of the Philips TDA1541 Silver
Crown multibit DAC chip, and another important part of the equation, a
CDM-44 transport.
Many designers still believe this to be the best and most suitable for
high quality CD players. Naim did too, which is why they bought as many
as they could get their hands on, in anticipation of the CDS's long and
happy production run. The transport was augmented by a quality, top loading
CD door arrangement and the famous Naim 'puck' which functioned much like
an old record stabiliser weight of yore.
Needless to say, the player sounded superb, fast propelling itself
into the realms of 'classic' CD players. Best characterised as a 'vinyl
lover's delight', it offers incredible musicality and firecracker dynamics
if properly set up. This isn't as easy as some, requiring careful levelling
(just like a turntable), and clean discs and laser (Naim recommend the
use of Blu-tack for this purpose, interestingly).
Many believe the CDS to be the most natural 'music making' CD player
around, describing it as akin to a good turntable. You get a rich, vivid,
tactile sound that simply gushes forth from your loudspeakers, without
giving so much as an inkling that it's a digital disc being spun. Listen
hard and you'll hear that trademark 'brightly lit' upper mid band and a
very slight fizzy quality to the treble, but you'll be churlish in the
extreme if you let this interfere with this CD spinner's deliciously musical
sound.
Downsides? The CDS is a bit finicky sometimes. Like the vinyl turntables
it emulates so well, it has more than a passing interest in the quality
of the disc surface itís playing. This means meticulous care on your part
if you aren't going to get all your silver frisbees sounding like remixes
from MC Scratchy.
The CDSII arrived in 1997, loosing the multibit DACs and early transport.
Heavily redesigned, it sounded quite different to the original - in some
ways better, in others a little more polite. In many ways, the newer version
is by far the more sensible option, but many love the original CDS for
its character and vintage appeal.
It's a deliciously musical little box (or two) of tricks, and many will
want it for this reason alone. The good news is that there are more around
second-hand than you'd think, the bad news is that they're expensive -
and sellers can more or less name their own price, circa £700.
This review was published in the February 2002 issue of
Hi-Fi World. No material may be reproduced from this review without the
written permission of the publisher. Copyright Audio Publishing Limited
|